French Pins vs Claw Clips: Which Hair Accessory Offers Better Hold for Thick or Curly Hair?

If you have thick or curly hair, you know the struggle: you find a gorgeous claw clip, spend five minutes perfecting your twist, and within an hour it’s sliding down or popping open. Sound familiar? You’re not alone. Many people with dense, textured hair have turned to French pins as an alternative, claiming they offer a more secure, long-lasting hold. But is that really true? In this guide, we’ll break down the differences between French pins and claw clips, evaluate which works best for thick or curly hair, and help you decide which accessory deserves a spot in your daily rotation.

At Gimme Beauty, we know that one size doesn’t fit all when it comes to hair accessories. That’s why we carry a range of options designed for different hair types and textures. Whether you’re team claw clip or curious about French pins, we’ll walk you through the pros and cons so you can make an informed choice. Let’s dive in.

What Are French Pins and How Do They Work?

French pins—also known as twist pins or hair forks—are long, U-shaped metal pins that you insert into a twisted or pinned-up bun. Unlike claw clips, which clamp down on the hair from the outside, French pins slide through the center of the bun and anchor the hair from within. This internal locking mechanism can be incredibly secure, especially for thick or curly hair that tends to push against external pressure.

Because French pins rely on tension and friction inside the bun, they often hold better than clips for certain updos. They’re also less likely to snag or pull individual strands, making them a gentle option for curly textures. At Gimme Beauty, the Signature Twist French Pins For Thick or Curly Hair are a fan favorite for exactly this reason—they’re designed with a smooth, rounded finish that glides through curls without catching.

• French pins work best with a twisted or coiled bun, not a simple ponytail.
• They are ideal for second-day hair or hair with some texture (natural or styled).
• Insert the pin at a slight angle, then twist it 180 degrees to lock the bun in place.

How Claw Clips Compare for Thick and Curly Hair

Claw clips are the go-to for quick, effortless styling. They work by clamping a section of hair between two hinged jaws, using spring tension to hold everything together. For fine or medium hair, a standard claw clip can easily secure a full twist or half-up style. But for thick or curly hair, the story is different: the clip may struggle to fully close, or the spring might not be strong enough to hold the weight of dense curls.

That said, not all claw clips are created equal. Larger clips with stronger springs—like the Double Down Rectangle Claw Clips For Thick or Curly Hair—are built to handle more volume. These clips have a wider jaw and reinforced hinges, so they can grip a larger section of hair without slipping. For those who prefer a more compact look, the Lay Back Claw Clip - Thick - Cobalt Crush offers a curved design that hugs the head while still accommodating thicker strands.

• Look for claw clips labeled "for thick hair" or "extra strong spring."
• Avoid clips with sharp edges that can snag curly hair.
• A good rule: if the clip doesn’t close completely, it’s too small for your hair.

Hold Comparison: Which Stays Put Longer?

When it comes to all-day hold, French pins have a slight edge—especially for high-activity days or humid weather. Because the pin sits inside the bun, it’s less likely to be dislodged by wind, movement, or even a nap. Many people with thick, curly hair report that a well-placed French pin can last 8–10 hours without needing adjustment. Claw clips, on the other hand, may need to be repositioned after a few hours, particularly if your hair is heavy or prone to slipping.

However, claw clips win on speed and versatility. You can put one in in under 10 seconds, while French pins require a bit more technique (twisting the hair into a stable bun first). For a quick errand or a casual coffee date, a claw clip is hard to beat. For a long workday or a night out, French pins may be the better bet. The Double Down Claw Clip For Most Hair Types - Mountain Blue is a great middle ground—it offers a secure hold with a slightly wider jaw that works well for medium to thick hair.

• French pins: best for all-day wear, buns, and protective styles.
• Claw clips: best for quick styling, half-up looks, and ponytails.
• If you have very thick or long hair, consider using two French pins for extra security.

Comfort and Hair Health: Which Is Gentler?

Both French pins and claw clips can be gentle on hair if used correctly, but they have different risk factors. Claw clips can sometimes pull or tug if the spring is too tight or if the clip is removed hastily. They can also create a pressure point on the scalp if worn in the same spot for hours. French pins, because they slide through the hair rather than clamping down, are less likely to cause tension headaches or breakage at the crown.

For curly hair, which is naturally more fragile, the smooth insertion of a French pin is often preferable. The Signature Twist French Pins are specifically designed with a polished finish to reduce friction. That said, claw clips can still be safe if you choose one with rounded teeth and a gentle spring. Avoid clips with sharp ridges or rough edges, and never force a clip closed—if it’s hard to snap shut, it’s probably too small.

• French pins are gentler for daily wear and less likely to cause breakage.
• Claw clips can be safe if you use the correct size and remove them carefully.
• Alternate between styles to give your hair and scalp a break from any single accessory.

How to Choose the Right Accessory for Your Hair Type

Still undecided? Here’s a quick cheat sheet. If you have fine or thin hair, a standard claw clip (like the Keep It Classic Claw Clips For Fine or Thinner Hair) will give you a secure hold without weighing your hair down. If you have thick, straight hair, a large claw clip or a French pin will both work—try the Double Down Rectangle Claw Clips for a quick option, or French pins for a sleek bun. If you have curly or coily hair, French pins are generally the safer, more reliable choice, but a sturdy claw clip can also work for looser curls or half-up styles.

Don’t be afraid to mix and match! Many people use a claw clip to secure the base of a bun and then add a French pin for extra stability. Experiment with both to see which feels most comfortable for your daily routine. And remember: the right tool can make all the difference between a frustrating hair day and a confident, put-together look.

• Fine hair: claw clips with a gentle grip (smaller size).
• Thick straight hair: large claw clips or French pins.
• Curly/coily hair: French pins or extra-large claw clips with strong springs.

Whether you choose a claw clip for its convenience or a French pin for its staying power, the best accessory is the one that makes you feel good and keeps your hair happy. At Gimme Beauty, we’ve got options for every texture and style. Ready to upgrade your hair game? Check out the Signature Twist French Pins For Thick or Curly Hair and discover a hold you can count on all day long.